There's a discussion going on on AFU that's reached the topic of what animals see when they look in a mirror.
Personally, my theory is that most animals see... their reflections, because while they might not have cognitive powers to the degrees humans have, they aren't THAT stupid. After all, it's always been intuitively obvious to us what's on the other side of that reflective surface - even if it's just a puddle. Sure, you'll see your bird doing displays at it as if to impress or intimidate the other bird - or maybe the bird's just going "Wow, I look COOL doing this!"
This would be why Spike's reaction to a mirror, the first time I showed him one, was to look, evince body language which suggested the notion "Oh. Right. Well, whatever," and wander away. And yes, I realise cats are one of the most self-aware animal types out there, but most people seem to assume that cats think the mirror shows another cat.
This would not be how Spike reacts to other cats.
Argh. It's such a superiority complex thing, and it's all on a continuum with the ridiculous paternalism you end up with people feeling towards "inferior" people, be they inferior by virtue of social class or race. Yes, applying to to people is a different scale of unworthy assumption, but it's just scale, not concept!
I feel strongly about some very odd things.
Personally, my theory is that most animals see... their reflections, because while they might not have cognitive powers to the degrees humans have, they aren't THAT stupid. After all, it's always been intuitively obvious to us what's on the other side of that reflective surface - even if it's just a puddle. Sure, you'll see your bird doing displays at it as if to impress or intimidate the other bird - or maybe the bird's just going "Wow, I look COOL doing this!"
This would be why Spike's reaction to a mirror, the first time I showed him one, was to look, evince body language which suggested the notion "Oh. Right. Well, whatever," and wander away. And yes, I realise cats are one of the most self-aware animal types out there, but most people seem to assume that cats think the mirror shows another cat.
This would not be how Spike reacts to other cats.
Argh. It's such a superiority complex thing, and it's all on a continuum with the ridiculous paternalism you end up with people feeling towards "inferior" people, be they inferior by virtue of social class or race. Yes, applying to to people is a different scale of unworthy assumption, but it's just scale, not concept!
I feel strongly about some very odd things.